MAC'S Teddy Eyeliner is a product that has been on my wish list for ages. I put off purchasing it because it's not a "high necessity item" for me. I mostly use black liner and it's usually gel. When I do use kohl it's to put it on my waterline. However, I found that after many neutral makeup looks I was left wanting something softer than black to use on the waterline and along the lash lines.
I found out about Teddy through Tanya Burr's You Tube videos. She's been using it for years. Since she doesn't do a lot of closeups, I didn't realize Teddy had shimmer in it until I used it for the first time. Surprisingly, I was not bothered by its because the gold/metallic-ness is gorgeous. It's not gritty in the slightest and the shimmers don't travel. I usually only use Teddy on the waterline and smudged along the lash line so the glitter is barely noticeable. On the picture above I used it to create a slight winged line so you would be able to appreciate how pretty it is. Teddy is creamy and doesn't tug. It also lasts very long and doesn't smudge on my waterline.
I highly recommend Teddy if you've been looking for an eyeliner pencil like this. I love it and it usually doesn't stay sharp for long, it gets a lot of use. Let me know what you think of it.