You may also like

Comments (30)
  1. Tasha 4 years ago

    Interesting to hear your thoughts on these. I actually haven't tried any shadow sticks but I will probably give these a miss due to their drier texture. I'd rather try out the Milani ones!

    Tasha // shiwashiful.

  2. Sarah AndBeauty 4 years ago

    Aw, what a shame! I do love the Milani ones though x

    and beauty or something.

  3. Anonymous 4 years ago

    Such a shame, since they look so gorgeous! I've been hunting for a rose gold, and while I am super in love with MAC Rubenesque at the moment, I'm still wondering about other products out there. Oh well, I guess I'll have to check out Michelle Phan's Em Ro's Gold eyeliner. 😛 x

    • TheBeautyMilk 4 years ago

      Haven't tried that, but from what I've seen Ro's Gold seems more yellow xx

  4. I love the flushed colour reminds me of the the maybelline tattoo shade that's super similar, shame it didn't live up to the high hopes! x

    Jamie-Lee|Glitter Infatuation Beauty & Lifestlye Blog!

  5. Esin D. 4 years ago

    They look so gorgeous, such a shame they failed texture-wise :/

  6. Boo, too bad about texture because they are beauts. Cream shadows and sticks can be soooo hit or miss!
    Kallie – But First, Coffee

    • TheBeautyMilk 4 years ago

      Most definitely. So many things can go wrong! They can be super greasy sometimes or the total opposite x

  7. Jen27 4 years ago

    Too bad the formula was a tad disappointing, but thanks for listing other affordable options that do the job better! Flushed really does look like a lovely everyday shimmer shade 🙂


  8. Meghan E 4 years ago

    Thanks for this review. I too love shadow sticks but find a lot of them to be hit and miss so it was great hearing your thoughts on the texture before picking up a whole bunch.
    Great post!

  9. casuallyawkward 4 years ago

    Sucks that these weren't as impressive as we'd like, the flushed color is still lovely on you however
    Stefanie | Casualllyawkward | Bloglovin

  10. Leanne Dolan 4 years ago

    It's a shame that the texture is shoddy. Flushed looks lovely!

    Leanne @ Leanne-Marie ​ x

  11. asianhomie101 4 years ago

    Such a shame that the texture of this wasn't good! Will know to skip this product! Thanks for the review!
    <3 Pauline, ­­Addicted to Makeup

  12. ThriftThick 4 years ago

    The Rose Gold looks especially dry… what a bummer!! At least NYX doesn't cause your bank account to weep so it wasn't tooooooo too much of a waste :/


    • TheBeautyMilk 4 years ago

      Yeah, I'm very glad but since I ordered these online I'm too lazy to return lol

  13. Masja 4 years ago

    Flushed looks absolutely gorgeous, too bad the texture isn't so great 🙁 I usually love jumbo pencils by NYX!

    My Makeup Mémoire

  14. Rikki Poynter 4 years ago

    I'm not a huge fan of cream shadows in general so I would've been passing on these anyway. I prefer powder.

    // RIKKI POYNTER MAKEUP: The Deaf Side of Beauty

  15. Mads M 4 years ago

    Great colours, shame they weren't quite what you were hoping

    Madeline | Its a Mads Mads World

  16. Bunny. I ♡ 4 years ago

    ahh its such a shame they arnt as good as they look because they do look really pretty xx


  17. Sandy 4 years ago

    These seemed like such winner before you mentioned the texture!! Such beautiful shades, nonetheless xx

  18. Vicki Bruce 4 years ago

    I love cream shadows too as they're so easy to wear. Its a shame these weren't great as the colours look pretty. Cream shadows are so hit & miss. I like the Laura Mercier & Bobbi Brown ones. They wear really well on me

  19. Sandra 4 years ago

    I'm super picky when it comes to the texture of cream eyeshadows as well for some reason. I just feel like it's tugging on my eyelid if they're too dry…

  20. weloveswatches 4 years ago

    Wow, I must say I am in love with Flushed!

  21. Zazie Bibi 4 years ago

    I'm currently loving the NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil in Cashmere, haven't heard of these though x

    A Little Treat | Beauty & Lifestyle Blog

  22. little henry lee 4 years ago

    it's a shame the texture of these is such a letdown. i find the same about the jumbo pencils, they're affordable and have a huge colour range but they're just not very good quality so i'd rather buy something else. unfortunately it probably won't be these though!

    little henry lee

  23. Amber McNiff 4 years ago

    Great post, I've never tried shadow sticks

  24. Anonymous 4 years ago

    flushed is stunning, but if it drags on the eye…… I think I'd rather spend my money on the new Color Tattoos!

  25. Dejhana Waite 4 years ago

    Oh no! I wanted to love these. Unfortunately, tugging on the eye is a big no no.

    Dejhana || Waite a Little

  26. Kevin 3 weeks ago

    To change or re-install your chuck into the quill spindle, this website a mallet to seat the shank of the chuck right into the quill spindle.


Post A Comment

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.